US Ruling That Trump Tariffs Are Unlawful Stirs Relief and Uncertainty

A US trade court ruling that blocked most of President Donald Trump’s tariffs and found he had overstepped his authority triggered some relief on financial markets on Thursday, while adding to the uncertainties weighing on the global economy.

Among the United States’ big trading partners, in the throes of negotiation with the Trump administration, Germany said it could not comment, as did the European Commission.

“We ask for your understanding that we cannot comment on the legal proceedings in the US, as they are still ongoing,” a spokesperson for Germany’s economy ministry said.

“We continue to hope that a mutually beneficial solution can be reached in the negotiations between the EU Commission and the US government.”

Winners on financial markets included chip makers, banks, luxury stocks and auto industry, all hit hard by tariff-led disruptions.

The US dollar rallied 0.2 percent against the yen and 0.3 percent against the Swiss franc as currencies and assets that have benefited from the tariff-induced market turmoil fell.

Wall Street stock index futures rose by more than 1.5 percent

The trade court ruling on Wednesday dealt a blow to Trump’s central policy of using tariffs to wring concessions from trading partners.

His administration immediately said it will appeal and analysts said investors will remain cautious as the White House explores its legal avenues.

Following a market revolt after Trump’s major tariff announcement on April 2, the US president paused most import duties for 90 days and said he would hammer out bilateral deals with trade partners.

But apart from a pact with Britain this month, agreements remain elusive and the court’s stay on the tariffs may dissuade countries like Japan from rushing into deals, analysts said.

Another pause in Trump’s stop-start trade policy could be helpful to opponents of his tariffs and to traders who relish volatility.

“Assuming that an appeal does not succeed in the next few days, the main win is time to prepare, and also a cap on the breadth of tariffs – which can’t exceed 15 percent for the time being,” George Lagarias, chief economist at Forvis Mazars international advisers, said.

Turmoil

Trump’s trade war has shaken makers of everything from luxury handbags and trainers to household appliances and cars as the price of raw materials has risen, supply chains have been disrupted and company strategies redrafted.

Drinks company Diageo, automakers General Motors and Ford are among those who have abandoned forecasts for the year ahead.

Non-US companies including Honda, Campari and pharmaceutical companies Roche and Novartis have said they are considering moving operations or expanding their US presence to mitigate the impact of tariffs.

As markets assessed the latest twist in the trade upheaval, European export-sensitive sectors, such as autos and luxury stocks, were among leading gainers on Thursday.

The pan-continental STOXX 600 was up 0.4 percent, while France’s CAC 40, which has a heavy weighting of luxury and bank stocks, rose 0.8 percent. Overall sentiment was also lifted by strong results late on Wednesday from AI bellwether Nvidia.

Spot gold declined for a fourth straight day, while US Treasury yields rose. Bond yields move inversely with prices.

But the gains in shares may be short-lived, analysts said, with those who relish risk making the most of them.

“I think we are in a period of higher volatility - we will get some more spikes on the way, I think. But volatility is the friend of the active investors,” Kevin Barker, global head of active equities, UBS Asset Management, told a media briefing.

By Sarah Marsh, Samuel Indyk

Learn more:

Trump Tariffs Hit European Luxury, Shares Tank

LVMH and Hermès stock fell about 3 percent and 4 percent respectively, in line with sector peers including Kering, Prada and Burberry, after the US president announced a 50 percent duty on imports from the European Union.